• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Bayside Creamery: Fresh, Generous Ice Cream & Shakes with Waterfront Views in Perth Amboy

Bayside Creamery, nestled along Perth Amboy’s scenic waterfront, offers a delightful escape for ice cream lovers. This family-owned gem is renowned for its generous portions, fair prices, and a diverse range of flavors, from classic favorites to unique options like fresh guava. The cozy ambiance, complemented by indoor and outdoor seating with water views, makes it perfect for summer evenings. Bayside also excels in sundaes, shakes, and floats, maintaining a long-standing local legend status. Meticulously maintained and welcoming, it’s a community treasure where every visit invites you to explore new tastes without long waits. Truly, a sweet spot worth savoring.

Bayside Creamery at a glance

  • Address 273 Front St #4416, Perth Amboy, NJ 08861, United States
  • Phone +1 732-442-7200
  • Restaurant type Ice cream shop .

Photos & Gallery

Bayside Creamery: Reviews & Ratings

Ananya Gupta
5

Like most of the reviewers are saying the ice cream here is pretty good but what's even better is the generous portions of their serving. In today's day and age, their prices are quite fair, hence. The guava flavored ice cream is highly recommended because of how fresh it tastes of the fruit. There is plenty of seating especially with the beautiful unobstructed view of the water.

Ron M
5

Cozy ice cream shop located along the Perth Amboy waterfront across from the marina and right next to the park. They have a good assortment of flavors. Good prices and nice ambiance. Clean and meticulously maintained. They have both indoor and outdoor seating. There is plenty of free parking nearby. Family owned shop, worth a visit. Asset to the community.

Sk. Adib Hossain
5

You got everything right there. They used to have homemade ice cream in the past. That was awesome. Its still good I'd say. Try everything, you'll like it. Whenever I go there , I try out different one every time. Waiting time is not that much. You get a lot of varieties too.

Wayne Scheuermann
5

One of the Best places in the area to get Ice Cream, Sundaes, and Shakes. This place has been around for years and is a Local Legend to us Locals! A must stop shop if in Perth Amboy or the surrounding area. Their Milkshakes are over the top as well as their Floats. Like I said, you have to visit, Especially since there are not many creameries left in general! Amazing!!!

Jane Wood
5

2025 Edit: Still a good place to go! perfect for summer night/ evening outs Beautiful and cozy place down near the waterfront! Definitely the best on warm summer days! Wide variety of flavors and has unique ones! My husband specifically gets the guava ice cream! Friendly and helpful staff and very reasonable price!

Dino Rodriguez
4

This is an extremely cozy family owned creamery with an expected variety of flavors. The decor inside is fun and with views to the marina immediately across the street, the outdoor seating is modest but comfortable during a pleasant day.

Tania Rosen
5

Nice little ice cream shop. They have a wide selection of Hershey's flavors with good pricing and generous portions. Staff is always friendly and helpful. They have some outdoor tables or you can cross the street and watch the boats and water from many benches or the docks.

Juan HiraYam
5

Great ice creams! They have indoor and outdoor seating and close to plenty of parking

Location

  • Bayside Creamery
    Bayside Creamery
    273 Front St #4416, Perth Amboy, NJ 08861, United States Hotline: +1 732-442-7200

Nestled along the scenic Perth Amboy waterfront, Bayside Creamery stands as a cherished local gem. This family-owned ice cream shop captures hearts not only with its generous portions but also with a remarkable variety of flavors that invite exploration. Walking into Bayside Creamery, the clean, cozy ambiance paired with ample indoor and outdoor seating offers a perfect retreat for both casual visits and summer evening outings.

What truly sets Bayside Creamery apart is the freshness and creativity behind its offerings. The standout guava ice cream bursts with authentic fruit flavors, delivering a refreshing taste that lingers pleasantly. Alongside this, the array of sundaes, shakes, and floats delight with rich textures and balanced sweetness, making every bite and sip memorable. The fair pricing, especially considering the hearty servings, enhances the overall appeal.

The location itself, right across from the marina and near the park, complements the experience with beautiful, unobstructed water views, allowing patrons to savor their treats in a serene setting. Friendly staff further enrich the visit, offering helpful recommendations and warm service.

In a time when creameries have become rare, Bayside Creamery remains a steadfast symbol of community pride and tradition. Whether you're a local or just passing through Perth Amboy, this spot demands a visit for anyone seeking quality ice cream with a genuine coastal vibe.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Wheelchair-accessible entrance
  • Service options
    • Takeaway
    • Delivery
    • Same-day delivery
  • Payments
    • Credit cards
    • Debit cards
    • NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards